Research Article
Volume 1 Issue 4 - 2017
Efficacy of Supplementation of Cloves and Cinnamon Capsules on Type II Diabetics
Assistant Professor, Department of Nutrition and Dietetics, Dr.N.G.P.Arts and Science College, Coimbatore-48
*Corresponding Author: Dr. M Sivasakthi, Assistant Professor, Department of Nutrition and Dietetics, Dr.N.G.P.Arts and Science College, Coimbatore-48, India.
Received: June 19, 2017; Published: July 15, 2017
Abstract
According to the famous quote of Hippocrates “Let food be thy medicine and medicine be the food”, natural plants, herbs, spices and phytochemicals serves as the wonderful foods for healthy life to rescue our life from dreadful ailments. Also the present study emphasise on supplementation of cinnamon and cloves powder enclosed in capsules to the diabetics showed favourable results on blood glucose and lipid profiles apart from other anthropometric indices. Experimental groups E1, E3 and E4 showed a significant weight reduction at 5% level. Significant difference was observed in BMI of all the experimental groups due to significant reduction in mean body weight of the diabetics after supplementation. The fasting blood glucose level between the experimental and control group revealed that groups E1, E2, E3 and E4 showed a significant difference at 1% level. As blood sugar level is an important aspect of the diabetics to be monitored to keep the values in the recommended range to lead a healthy life.
Introduction
Diabetes is a world-wide metabolic disorder, with a cumulative global trend and of particular concern to India. International Diabetes Federation estimates that number of diabetic patients in India doubled from 19 million in 1995 to 40.9 million in 2007. It is probable to increase to 69.9 million by 2025 (Neogi, 2007). The indigenous preparations from various parts of herbal plants are used for functional food preparations, which provide additional health benefits beyond basic nutrition for treatment of diabetes (CSPI, 2002).
Spices like cinnamon and cloves have insulin potentiating activity and due to this property, they might have a role in glucose and lipid metabolism. Cinnamon acts as an antiseptic, antibacterial, antifungal, astringent and aids in digestion, antispasmodic, antiviral, antinausea, antiflatulence, anti-diarrhoeal, carminative, hypoglycemic, promoting sweat, uterine stimulant and also a warming stimulant (Baker and Guttieriz, 2008). The health benefits of clove oil are noted as antibacterial, antimicrobial, antifungal, antiseptic, antiviral, aphrodisiac and stimulating properties (Encyclopedia of Medicinal Plants, 2000). The present study focused on effect of supplementation of cloves and cinnamon on Type II Diabetics around the age group of 40-60 years.
Materials and Methods
The study was carried out in Government Hospital, Periyakulam at Theni District in Tamil Nadu State, as the investigator is familiar with these areas. The hospital authorities were very helpful and gave permission to conduct the study. For the purpose of the initial survey, 120 diabetics receiving treatment at the Hospital were interviewed with the help of the doctors. From the 120 adults, fifty members, each 10 consisted in the 4 Experimental groups and the remaining 10 formed the control group who were in the age group of 40 to 60 years were approached and based on the clinical symptoms as identified by a Physician were selected for the study.
Supplementation of spice capsules
Anti-diabetic spices Cinnamon with eugenol as an active principle and Methyl Chalcone Polymers (MHCP), a potential compound against insulin metabolism and Cloves (Bharate, 2001) were the spices were obtained from Departmental store, cleaned and the pulverized product was kept in air-tight containers. Each capsule consisted of 500 mg of spice powders which is the dosage recommended for each capsule for the supplementation study. For the diabetics of Experimental group I, four capsules of cinnamon amounting to 2g were given daily and requested to consume 2 capsules along with their breakfast and 2 capsules after the dinner. This supplementation was conducted for a period of 90 days. Each clove capsules contained 500 mg of pure clove powder. The diabetics of Experimental group II were given 4 capsules per day and asked to consume 2 capsules with breakfast and 2 after dinner.
Anti-diabetic spices Cinnamon with eugenol as an active principle and Methyl Chalcone Polymers (MHCP), a potential compound against insulin metabolism and Cloves (Bharate, 2001) were the spices were obtained from Departmental store, cleaned and the pulverized product was kept in air-tight containers. Each capsule consisted of 500 mg of spice powders which is the dosage recommended for each capsule for the supplementation study. For the diabetics of Experimental group I, four capsules of cinnamon amounting to 2g were given daily and requested to consume 2 capsules along with their breakfast and 2 capsules after the dinner. This supplementation was conducted for a period of 90 days. Each clove capsules contained 500 mg of pure clove powder. The diabetics of Experimental group II were given 4 capsules per day and asked to consume 2 capsules with breakfast and 2 after dinner.
For the Experimental group III, a mixed proportion of cinnamon and cloves in the ratio of 1.5:0.5g (2g) was supplemented and instructed to consume 2 capsules of 500 mg each along with breakfast and dinner for a period of 3 months. Likewise, a mixed proportion of cinnamon and cloves in the ratio of 0.5:1.5g (2g) was supplemented for Experimental group IV and 2 capsules of 500 mg was taken along with breakfast and dinner, whereas Control group received no supplementation.
Assessment of the nutritional status
The diabetics were weighed using weighing balance to the nearest 0.1 kg and heights were measured using non-flexible fiberglass tape to the nearest 0.1 cm. BMI was calculated using the formula, BMI = Weight (Kg)/ Height (m2), (WHO, Diabetes Care, 2004). Waist Hip Ratio was also calculated for the diabetics.
The diabetics were weighed using weighing balance to the nearest 0.1 kg and heights were measured using non-flexible fiberglass tape to the nearest 0.1 cm. BMI was calculated using the formula, BMI = Weight (Kg)/ Height (m2), (WHO, Diabetes Care, 2004). Waist Hip Ratio was also calculated for the diabetics.
Analysis of bio-chemical parameters
Biochemical parameters were determined for the 50 diabetics. For the analysis, 5ml of the blood was drawn from all the diabetics before and after supplementation. Blood glucose levels of the subjects were estimated using the standard procedure of Enzymatic Calorimetric test GOD-PAP method given by Trinder (1972). Haemoglobin and glycosylated haemoglobin was estimated by cyanmethaemoglobin method (WHO, 1999) and Immuno assays (Frank, 1988).
Biochemical parameters were determined for the 50 diabetics. For the analysis, 5ml of the blood was drawn from all the diabetics before and after supplementation. Blood glucose levels of the subjects were estimated using the standard procedure of Enzymatic Calorimetric test GOD-PAP method given by Trinder (1972). Haemoglobin and glycosylated haemoglobin was estimated by cyanmethaemoglobin method (WHO, 1999) and Immuno assays (Frank, 1988).
Total cholesterol was estimated by using the Enzymatic Calorimetric test CHOD-PAP method suggested by Carl., et al. 2006) and Serum triglycerides by Enzymatic GPO-PAP method (Carl., et al. 2006). HDL cholesterol, estimation was done using the enzymatic method suggested by Friedwald., et al. (1972). Similarly, serum LDL-C and VLDL-C were calculated using the equation given by Fried Wald (1972).
Statistical analysis
The data collected on food intake, bio-chemical parameters of the subjects was analyzed using appropriate statistical package like t-test and interpreted.
The data collected on food intake, bio-chemical parameters of the subjects was analyzed using appropriate statistical package like t-test and interpreted.
Results and Discussion
Background information
The background information on the subjects revealed that a majority of 38 % were in the age group of 51-55 years. Regarding their educational status, 20 % were illiterates and almost 19, 18, 17 and 14 % have studied up to higher secondary, high school, primary and under graduate education respectively. It was observed that only 12% were post graduates. Regarding the occupational status, a majority of 46% of them were involved in business.
The background information on the subjects revealed that a majority of 38 % were in the age group of 51-55 years. Regarding their educational status, 20 % were illiterates and almost 19, 18, 17 and 14 % have studied up to higher secondary, high school, primary and under graduate education respectively. It was observed that only 12% were post graduates. Regarding the occupational status, a majority of 46% of them were involved in business.
As far as income is concerned, 62% belonged to low income group based on HUDCO (2004) classification and 38 % had a monthly income between Rs.4500-Rs.7500 and none of them had a monthly income above Rs. 7501. It is also observed that a majority of 52% belonged to nuclear family system. Regarding food expenditure, a majority of 42 % of the diabetics spent between Rs.1001–1500 monthly followed by 28% of diabetics who spent Rs.1501-2000 monthly for food and it was noted that none of them had spent more than Rs.2500 for food. Among the diabetics, 63 % of them were involved in moderate work and 28 %were sedentary workers.
Dietary pattern
Among the 120 diabetics, a majority of 85% were non-vegetarians and 13 % of them were vegetarians. With regard to the meal pattern, a majority of 85% had the habit of consuming three meals per day. Only 9 and 6% of the diabetics had the habit of taking less than 3 meals and more than 3 meals per day respectively. Vegetarians had lower plasma fat than the meat eaters (Allen., et al. 2000).
Among the 120 diabetics, a majority of 85% were non-vegetarians and 13 % of them were vegetarians. With regard to the meal pattern, a majority of 85% had the habit of consuming three meals per day. Only 9 and 6% of the diabetics had the habit of taking less than 3 meals and more than 3 meals per day respectively. Vegetarians had lower plasma fat than the meat eaters (Allen., et al. 2000).
Consumption of fats and oils
Regarding the consumption of fats and oils, it is revealed that a majority of 29% of the diabetics were consuming palm oil because of its low cost, followed by nearly 20% consuming sunflower oil. About 18% of them were consuming gingelly oil and refined oil, whereas only 9% consumed ground nut oil. Riccardi., et al. (2008) documented that a diet based on low fat, low carbohydrate and high fiber content may protect against diabetes.
Regarding the consumption of fats and oils, it is revealed that a majority of 29% of the diabetics were consuming palm oil because of its low cost, followed by nearly 20% consuming sunflower oil. About 18% of them were consuming gingelly oil and refined oil, whereas only 9% consumed ground nut oil. Riccardi., et al. (2008) documented that a diet based on low fat, low carbohydrate and high fiber content may protect against diabetes.
Food consumption pattern
A majority of 68% of the diabetics were consuming cereals daily and 25% weekly once, 59% of the diabetics had consumed pulses daily. A maximum of 65% were using vegetables weekly in their diet, A majority of 67% of the diabetics consumed other vegetables weekly once while 23% daily. Consumption of roots and tubers revealed that 44 and 38% were consuming fortnightly. It is revealed that, a maximum of 58 and 44%of the diabetics were consuming non-vegetarian food items and junk food items weekly and occasionally respectively. Jakubowicz (2008) reported that higher intake of fruits and vegetables will decrease the risk of diabetes.
A majority of 68% of the diabetics were consuming cereals daily and 25% weekly once, 59% of the diabetics had consumed pulses daily. A maximum of 65% were using vegetables weekly in their diet, A majority of 67% of the diabetics consumed other vegetables weekly once while 23% daily. Consumption of roots and tubers revealed that 44 and 38% were consuming fortnightly. It is revealed that, a maximum of 58 and 44%of the diabetics were consuming non-vegetarian food items and junk food items weekly and occasionally respectively. Jakubowicz (2008) reported that higher intake of fruits and vegetables will decrease the risk of diabetes.
Life style pattern
It is clear that nearly 12-14% of the diabetics had the habit of walking 30 and 60 minutes daily respectively, while 44 % of them did not do any type of exercises. It is found that a majority 86% of the diabetics were smokers. About 50 % of the diabetics had smoking habit for more than 10 years and a majority of 56% was consuming alcohol. Forty five per cent of them had the habit of consuming betel leaves daily. The beverage consumption among them revealed that about 29, 28, 18 and 25% were consuming coffee/tea/milk/health drinks daily. Walking is the simplest way of maintenance of body weight (Jackicic., et al. 2003).
It is clear that nearly 12-14% of the diabetics had the habit of walking 30 and 60 minutes daily respectively, while 44 % of them did not do any type of exercises. It is found that a majority 86% of the diabetics were smokers. About 50 % of the diabetics had smoking habit for more than 10 years and a majority of 56% was consuming alcohol. Forty five per cent of them had the habit of consuming betel leaves daily. The beverage consumption among them revealed that about 29, 28, 18 and 25% were consuming coffee/tea/milk/health drinks daily. Walking is the simplest way of maintenance of body weight (Jackicic., et al. 2003).
Disease Condition
A majority of diabetics had this disease for a period of 6-10 years whereas 27% were suffering from the disease for a longer period of 11-20 years. Familial history indicated that a majority had grandparents or one of the parents with the disease. Few of them had both the parents and their relatives suffering from the disease.
A majority of diabetics had this disease for a period of 6-10 years whereas 27% were suffering from the disease for a longer period of 11-20 years. Familial history indicated that a majority had grandparents or one of the parents with the disease. Few of them had both the parents and their relatives suffering from the disease.
Clinical Status
Table I depicted that a majority of 13% each of the diabetics had polyphagia and excessive sweating and each 7-8 % of them had shivering, hypertension, constipation and insomnia. Nearly 3-4% of the diabetics had other symptoms of breathlessness, blurred vision, polydipsia, delayed wound healing, nocturia, fatigue, inability to work, palpitation and peptic ulcer.
Table I depicted that a majority of 13% each of the diabetics had polyphagia and excessive sweating and each 7-8 % of them had shivering, hypertension, constipation and insomnia. Nearly 3-4% of the diabetics had other symptoms of breathlessness, blurred vision, polydipsia, delayed wound healing, nocturia, fatigue, inability to work, palpitation and peptic ulcer.
Symptoms* | Number | Percent |
Polyuria | 11 | 9 |
Polydipsia | 5 | 4 |
Polyphagia | 15 | 13 |
Delayed wound healing | 5 | 4 |
Blurred vision | 3 | 3 |
Hypertension | 10 | 8 |
Nocturia | 5 | 4 |
Constipation | 9 | 8 |
Fatigue | 5 | 4 |
Shivering | 8 | 7 |
Inability to work | 5 | 4 |
Palpitation | 5 | 4 |
Breathlessness | 4 | 3 |
Peptic Ulcer | 5 | 4 |
Insomnia | 10 | 8 |
Excessive sweating | 15 | 13 |
Table 1: Prevalence of Clinical Symptoms among Diabetics.
*Multiple responses
*Multiple responses
Mean food intake
It is clear that there was a higher deficit in the mean intake of roots and tubers (68%), other vegetables (68%), sugars (59%), cereals (57%), milk and milk products (56%) and green leafy vegetables (55%) by the diabetics. The deficits were found to be lesser for pulses (30%) and fruits (43%). Intake of fats and oils and meat and fish were slightly higher by 8 and 23% respectively. Individuals of high risk Type II diabetes should be encouraged to achieve USDA recommendation for dietary fiber (14g fiber/1000 Kcal) and foods containing whole grains (ADA, 2004).
It is clear that there was a higher deficit in the mean intake of roots and tubers (68%), other vegetables (68%), sugars (59%), cereals (57%), milk and milk products (56%) and green leafy vegetables (55%) by the diabetics. The deficits were found to be lesser for pulses (30%) and fruits (43%). Intake of fats and oils and meat and fish were slightly higher by 8 and 23% respectively. Individuals of high risk Type II diabetes should be encouraged to achieve USDA recommendation for dietary fiber (14g fiber/1000 Kcal) and foods containing whole grains (ADA, 2004).
Mean nutrient intake
It is clear that there was a 77.5% deficit in the intake of fiber, 54.4 deficit in β-carotene, 34.5% in energy intake, 27.5% in carbohydrates and 20.3% in protein respectively when compared with the RDA values given by ICMR (2004). There was an excess mean intake of niacin by 75%, vitamin C by 62.3%, and riboflavin by 61.4%. There was a slightly higher intake of fat (31.4%) and of calcium (11%), thiamine (8.3%) and intake of iron (13.3%) was observed as the least deficits of nutrients among the diabetics. In general, the intake of foods and nutrients by the diabetics was found to be imbalanced.
It is clear that there was a 77.5% deficit in the intake of fiber, 54.4 deficit in β-carotene, 34.5% in energy intake, 27.5% in carbohydrates and 20.3% in protein respectively when compared with the RDA values given by ICMR (2004). There was an excess mean intake of niacin by 75%, vitamin C by 62.3%, and riboflavin by 61.4%. There was a slightly higher intake of fat (31.4%) and of calcium (11%), thiamine (8.3%) and intake of iron (13.3%) was observed as the least deficits of nutrients among the diabetics. In general, the intake of foods and nutrients by the diabetics was found to be imbalanced.
Awareness regarding diabetic diets
About 42% of diabetics reported fruits are the antioxidant rich foods, 48% agreed that spices have anti-diabetic property, while 52% opined that ragi can be included in the diet, whereas 78% opined that rice and wheat could be avoided from the diet as they increase blood sugar level. WHO estimates that 80% of the World’s population presently uses herbal and spice medicine as primary health care (Walter., et al. 2000).
About 42% of diabetics reported fruits are the antioxidant rich foods, 48% agreed that spices have anti-diabetic property, while 52% opined that ragi can be included in the diet, whereas 78% opined that rice and wheat could be avoided from the diet as they increase blood sugar level. WHO estimates that 80% of the World’s population presently uses herbal and spice medicine as primary health care (Walter., et al. 2000).
Nutrient content of Cinnamon and Cloves
Among the two spices analyzed, energy content of cloves was found to be 281.0 Kcal being higher than cinnamon which contained 186.3 Kcal for 100 grams. It was observed that protein, fat, vitamin C and crude fibre content of cloves was 7.8g, 1.72g, 36 mg and 14.63 g per 100g respectively which was slightly higher than cinnamon which had 7.12g, 0.81g, 29.3 mg and 9.59g respectively. Calcium content of cinnamon was 578.3 mg which was slightly higher than cloves 563.2 mg. The phosphorus content of cinnamon (0.06 mg) was much lower than cloves which had 71.1mg. Carbohydrate, thiamine, riboflavin, niacin and potassium content of both spices were found to be similar, whereas higher amount of 52.8µg of β carotene was found in cinnamon than cloves which had only 21.2 µg of β carotene. Cloves were found to have slightly higher amount of moisture (14.3g) than cinnamon (6.3g) (NIN manual, 2007).
Among the two spices analyzed, energy content of cloves was found to be 281.0 Kcal being higher than cinnamon which contained 186.3 Kcal for 100 grams. It was observed that protein, fat, vitamin C and crude fibre content of cloves was 7.8g, 1.72g, 36 mg and 14.63 g per 100g respectively which was slightly higher than cinnamon which had 7.12g, 0.81g, 29.3 mg and 9.59g respectively. Calcium content of cinnamon was 578.3 mg which was slightly higher than cloves 563.2 mg. The phosphorus content of cinnamon (0.06 mg) was much lower than cloves which had 71.1mg. Carbohydrate, thiamine, riboflavin, niacin and potassium content of both spices were found to be similar, whereas higher amount of 52.8µg of β carotene was found in cinnamon than cloves which had only 21.2 µg of β carotene. Cloves were found to have slightly higher amount of moisture (14.3g) than cinnamon (6.3g) (NIN manual, 2007).
Impact of Supplementation of functional ingredient capsules on anthropometric indices
Height
The mean height of the diabetics showed very negligible change after supplementation and no significant difference was noticed between initial and final values between the different groups.
Height
The mean height of the diabetics showed very negligible change after supplementation and no significant difference was noticed between initial and final values between the different groups.
Weight
The mean weight of all the experimental groups showed a reduction in weight ranging from 0.41 kg to 1.15 kg, the control group showed an increase of 0.37 kg. Experimental groups I, III and IV showed a significant weight difference between initial and final values at 5% level. The weight of all the diabetics were more than the weight of a reference Indian man (60 kg), Verma (2000).
The mean weight of all the experimental groups showed a reduction in weight ranging from 0.41 kg to 1.15 kg, the control group showed an increase of 0.37 kg. Experimental groups I, III and IV showed a significant weight difference between initial and final values at 5% level. The weight of all the diabetics were more than the weight of a reference Indian man (60 kg), Verma (2000).
Body Mass Index
Significant difference was observed in BMI of all the experimental groups due to reduction in mean body weight after supplementation except control group. However the mean BMI of the groups before and after supplementation was identified under the category of Grade I Overweight [(25-29.9) kg/m2], (WHO (2004).
Significant difference was observed in BMI of all the experimental groups due to reduction in mean body weight after supplementation except control group. However the mean BMI of the groups before and after supplementation was identified under the category of Grade I Overweight [(25-29.9) kg/m2], (WHO (2004).
Waist Hip Ratio
The mean WHR of the experimental groups before and after supplementation showed a very negligible change and hence no significant difference was observed in all the groups. Diabetes Care, WHO (2001) pointed out that waist hip ratio more than 0.80 in women and 0.90 in men indicate central body fat distribution. In the present study, most of the diabetics were under central body fat distribution, because their WHR was above the normal level (0.90) showed insulin resistance and inefficient management of diabetes.
The mean WHR of the experimental groups before and after supplementation showed a very negligible change and hence no significant difference was observed in all the groups. Diabetes Care, WHO (2001) pointed out that waist hip ratio more than 0.80 in women and 0.90 in men indicate central body fat distribution. In the present study, most of the diabetics were under central body fat distribution, because their WHR was above the normal level (0.90) showed insulin resistance and inefficient management of diabetes.
Impact of Supplementation of functional ingredient Capsules on Blood Profile
Mean Fasting Blood Glucose levels
Mean Fasting Blood Glucose levels
Groups | Fasting Blood Glucose (mg/dl) | Mean Difference | ‘t’ value Initial Vs Final |
‘t’ value Between Groups |
|
Initial | Final | ||||
Experimental group I (E1) (Cinnamon-2g) | 166.1 ± 19.09 | 147.4 ± 19.66 | 18.7 ± 4.85 | 11.56** | E1 Vs E2 1.13NS E1 Vs E3 0.61NS E1 Vs E4 0.40NS E1 Vs C 4.22** |
Experimental group II (E2) (Cloves-2g) | 165.8 ±17.45 | 144.1±19.51 | 21.7 ± 6.32 | 10.30** | E2 Vs E3 0.37NS E2 Vs E4 1.29NS E2 Vs C 4.79** |
Experimental group III (E3) (1½ g Cinnamon, ½ g Cloves) |
158.8 ± 24.93 | 138.3 ± 23.73 | 20.5 ± 7.29 | 8.43** | E3 Vs E4 0.87NS E3 Vs C 4.27** |
Experimental group IV (E4) (½ g Cinnamon, 1½ g Cloves) |
171 ± 12.86 | 153.5 ± 12.94 | 17.5 ± 7.41 | 7.08** | E4 Vs C 3.47** |
Control group (C) | 156.9 ± 17.56 | 160.4 ± 18.77 | 3.5 ± 9.65 | 1.08NS | - |
Table 2: Mean fasting blood glucose levels of the diabetics.
**Significant at 1% level NS - Not Significant.
**Significant at 1% level NS - Not Significant.
The fasting blood glucose values of the diabetics were higher than (70-110 mg/dl) normal values given by ADA (2006) shown in Table II. The mean fasting blood glucose level in experimental groups showed a reduction ranging from 17.5 to 21.7 mg/dl with E2 showing a higher decrease. The differences were statistically significant at 1% level among all the experimental groups than control group. The decrease in blood glucose level of the patients may be attributed to eugenol and cayophyllene present in cinnamon and cloves (Khan., et al. 2003).
Mean Post Prandial Blood Glucose levels
The final post prandial blood glucose values of all the diabetics of the experimental groups were found to decrease from the initial values except the control group after supplementation. The differences between the initial and final values were statistically significant among the experimental groups E1, E2, and E4 at one per cent level and in group E3 supplemented with a combined proportion of cinnamon and clove capsules (1½: ½ g) it was significant at 5% level. While on comparison, E1 was found to be better than E3 and E4 groups and with control group at 1% level of significance. Sharma (2003) revealed that cinnamon and clove plays an indispensable role in the management of blood glucose and lipid levels.
The final post prandial blood glucose values of all the diabetics of the experimental groups were found to decrease from the initial values except the control group after supplementation. The differences between the initial and final values were statistically significant among the experimental groups E1, E2, and E4 at one per cent level and in group E3 supplemented with a combined proportion of cinnamon and clove capsules (1½: ½ g) it was significant at 5% level. While on comparison, E1 was found to be better than E3 and E4 groups and with control group at 1% level of significance. Sharma (2003) revealed that cinnamon and clove plays an indispensable role in the management of blood glucose and lipid levels.
Mean Post Prandial Blood Glucose levels
Figure 1: Mean Post Prandial blood glucose levels of the diabetics.
Mean Glycosylated Haemoglobin levels
The initial HbA1c values of the diabetics were above the good control range of (5.6 to 7%) recommended by Praful., et al. (1998). The mean initial percentage of HbA1c levels of groups E1, E2, E3 and E4 before supplementation was observed to be 9.43, 9.64, 9.73 and 9.34 respectively and notably it was reduced to 8.78, 9.07, 9.11 and 9%t after supplementation, and the differences were significant at 1% level among groups. The differences between experimental and control groups revealed that groups E1, E2 and E3 showed significant differences when compared with control group at 1% level. It was proved that group E2 supplemented with 2g of cloves which consists of eugenol had significantly reduced the mean HbA1c after supplementation (Babu., et al. 2007). None of the diabetics were found to be anaemic, when compared with the normal values (13.5 to 16.5 g/dl) for adult men given by Carl., et al. (2006). All the experimental groups showed a slight increase in the haemoglobin values ranging from 0.25 to 0.39 g/dl which were significant at 5% level among E1, E2 and E3 only whereas a 1% level of significance was observed among E4 group.
On comparison, the groups E1, E2, E3 and E4 and control group revealed that group E4 showed a significant difference at 1% level with control group. Group E4 supplemented with a combination of 1½ g of cloves and ½ g of cinnamon powder had a significant role in increasing haemoglobin level was proved.
Groups | Glycosylated Haemoglobin (%) | Mean Difference | ‘t’ value Initial Vs Final |
‘t’ value Between Groups |
|
Initial | Final | ||||
Experimental group I (E1) (Cinnamon-2g) | 9.43 ± 0.66 | 8.78 ± 0.98 | 0.65 ± 0.66 | 2.9* | E1 Vs E2 0.28NS E1 Vs E3 0.10NS E1 Vs E4 1.23NS E1 Vs C 2.94** |
Experimental group II (E2) (Cloves-2g) | 9.64 ± 1.40 | 9.07 ± 1.57 | 0.57 ± 0.52 | 3.27** | E2 Vs E3 0.19NS E2 Vs E4 1.09NS E2 Vs C 3.08** |
Experimental group III (E3) (1½ g Cinnamon, ½ g Cloves) | 9.73 ± 1.66 | 9.1 ± 1.86 | 0.62 ± 0.58 | 3.16* | E3 Vs E4 1.27NS E3 Vs C 3.08** |
Experimental group IV (E4) (½ g Cinnamon, 1½ g Cloves) | 9.34 ±1.01 | 9.0± 1.08 | 0.34 ± 0.36 | 2.83* | E4 Vs C 2.58* |
Control group (C) | 10.79 ± 1.53 | 10.83 ± 1.52 | 0.004 ± 0.06 | 0.17NS | - |
Table 3: Mean glycosylated haemoglobin levels of the diabetics.
**Significant at 1% level *Significant at 5% level NS - Not Significant.
**Significant at 1% level *Significant at 5% level NS - Not Significant.
Mean Total Cholesterol levels
Groups | Total Cholesterol (mg/dl) | Mean Difference | ‘t’ value Initial Vs Final |
‘t’ value Between Groups |
|
Initial | Final | ||||
Experimental group I (E1) (Cinnamon-2g) |
225.7 ± 19.64 | 217.4 ± 19.49 | 8.3 ± 8.45 | 2.94* | E1 Vs E2 0.41NS E1 Vs E3 1.18NS E1 Vs E4 1.66NS E1 Vs C 1.86NS |
Experimental group II (E2) (Cloves-2g) |
220.7 ± 14.30 | 213.7 ± 15.79 | 7.0 ± 4.44 | 4.7* | E2 Vs E3 1.16NS E2 Vs E4 3.23 ** E2 Vs C 2.04NS |
Experimental group III (E3), (1½ g Cinnamon, ½ g Cloves) |
210.2 ± 20.49 | 205.7 ± 23.48 | 4.5 ± 4.83 | 2.7* | E3 Vs E4 4.26** E3 Vs C 1.03NS |
Experimental group IV (E4) (½ g Cinnamon, 1½ g Cloves) |
207.4 ± 14.27 | 193.9 ± 14.43 | 13.5 ± 4.14 | 9.78** | E4 Vs C 4.75 ** |
Control group (C) | 237.4 ± 35.58 | 235.6 ± 34.80 | 1.8 ± 6.22 | 0.86NS | - |
Table 4: Mean total cholesterol levels of the diabetics.
**Significant at 1% level *Significant at 5% level NS - Not Significant.
**Significant at 1% level *Significant at 5% level NS - Not Significant.
The differences in initial and final values were significant at 1% level among E2 and E4 groups, whereas at 5% level among E1 and E3 groups. There was a reduction in the mean cholesterol levels of diabetics after supplementation of spice capsules ranging from 4.5 to 13.5 mg/dl among experimental groups with a maximum reduction among E4 group. Control group also showed a slight reduction. Falcon (2002) described that supplementation of 1-3 grams of cloves and cinnamon powder would decrease serum triglycerides, total cholesterol and LDL cholesterol.
Mean Triglyceride levels
The mean triglyceride levels of groups after supplementation of spice capsules were found to decrease among experimental groups ranging from 6.7 to 12.2 mg/dl with a slight increase of 0.6 mg/dl among control group. There was a significant difference in mean total cholesterol levels at 5% level among groups E1 and E3 and at 1% level among E2 and E4 groups after supplementation. All the experimental groups showed significant difference with the control group, with E2 and E4 groups showing a highly significant difference at 1% level whereas E1 and E3 showed a difference at 5% level. The differences among the experimental groups were not significant. Vasantlad (2004) stated cinnamon improves serum triglycerides and cholesterol levels of which 2-6 grams daily was suggested.
The mean triglyceride levels of groups after supplementation of spice capsules were found to decrease among experimental groups ranging from 6.7 to 12.2 mg/dl with a slight increase of 0.6 mg/dl among control group. There was a significant difference in mean total cholesterol levels at 5% level among groups E1 and E3 and at 1% level among E2 and E4 groups after supplementation. All the experimental groups showed significant difference with the control group, with E2 and E4 groups showing a highly significant difference at 1% level whereas E1 and E3 showed a difference at 5% level. The differences among the experimental groups were not significant. Vasantlad (2004) stated cinnamon improves serum triglycerides and cholesterol levels of which 2-6 grams daily was suggested.
Mean LDL Cholesterol levels
Groups | LDL Cholesterol (mg/dl) | Mean Difference | ‘t’ value Initial Vs Final |
‘t’ value Between groups |
|
Initial | Final | ||||
Experimental group I (E1) (Cinnamon-2g) | 160.5 ± 45.93 | 135.9 ± 53.98 | 24.6 ± 24.35 | 3.03* | E1 Vs E2 1.47NS E1 Vs E3 1.92NS E1 Vs E4 1.35NS E1 Vs C 2.84* |
Experimental group II (E2) (Cloves-2g) | 148.5 ± 14.51 | 136.2 ± 16.02 | 12.3 ± 5.61 | 6.56** | E2 Vs E3 1.27NS E2 Vs E4 0.53NS E2 Vs C 5.14** |
Experimental group III (E3) (1½ g Cinnamon, ½ g Cloves) |
135.5 ± 22.95 | 127.4 ± 24.31 | 8.1 ± 8.18 | 2.97* | E3 Vs E4 1.80NS E3 Vs C 2.33* |
Experimental group IV (E4) (½ g Cinnamon, 1½ g Cloves) |
130.9 ± 17.40 | 117.4 ± 17.80 | 13.5 ± 3.74 | 10.82** | E4 Vs C 7.58** |
Control group (C) | 164.5 ± 40.59 | 163.2 ± 40.12 | 1.3 ± 3.16 | 1.23NS | - |
Table 5: Mean Ldl Cholesterol Levels of The Diabetics.
**Significant at 1% level *Significant at 5% level NS - Not Significant.
**Significant at 1% level *Significant at 5% level NS - Not Significant.
From the table it is revealed that the LDL cholesterol levels of diabetics decreased after supplementation ranging from 8.1 to 24.6 mg/dl among all the experimental groups with slight reduction in the control group. A significant reduction at 1% level was observed in groups E2 and E4, while significant difference at 5% level was observed among groups E1 and E3 after supplementation and no significant difference in the control group.
Mean HDL Cholesterol levels
A comparison between HDL cholesterol levels of groups revealed that a significant increase at 1% level was observed among group E1 and control group, whereas a significant increase at 5% level was found among E3 and E4 compared with control group and also between groups of E1 and E2. Babyskaria., et al. (2007) reported that oral administration of cinnamon which has methyl chalcone polymers will significantly improve blood lipid levels.
A comparison between HDL cholesterol levels of groups revealed that a significant increase at 1% level was observed among group E1 and control group, whereas a significant increase at 5% level was found among E3 and E4 compared with control group and also between groups of E1 and E2. Babyskaria., et al. (2007) reported that oral administration of cinnamon which has methyl chalcone polymers will significantly improve blood lipid levels.
Mean VLDL Cholesterol levels
It is reported that most of the diabetics had VLDL values above the recommended range, but the level was reduced after supplementation. The mean VLDL cholesterol levels showed a decrease after the supplementation ranging from 5.2 to 14.5 mg/dl with a maximum reduction among E4 group and control group also showed a slight reduction. A significant reduction in mean VLDL levels was observed in E1 and E4 (42.5 to 28 mg/dl) at 1% level after 3 months of spice capsules supplementation. Rajamani., et al. (2005) reported that the administration of spice mixture of cloves and cinnamon maintains glucose metabolism and plasma lipid profile especially LDL and VLDL cholesterol levels.
It is reported that most of the diabetics had VLDL values above the recommended range, but the level was reduced after supplementation. The mean VLDL cholesterol levels showed a decrease after the supplementation ranging from 5.2 to 14.5 mg/dl with a maximum reduction among E4 group and control group also showed a slight reduction. A significant reduction in mean VLDL levels was observed in E1 and E4 (42.5 to 28 mg/dl) at 1% level after 3 months of spice capsules supplementation. Rajamani., et al. (2005) reported that the administration of spice mixture of cloves and cinnamon maintains glucose metabolism and plasma lipid profile especially LDL and VLDL cholesterol levels.
Conclusion
- Effect of supplementation of spice powder capsules for a period of 3 months to the diabetics revealed that there was very negligible changes observed in the mean height and Waist Hip Ratio between the different groups. whereas Significant difference was observed in BMI of all the experimental groups due to significant reduction in mean body weight of the diabetics after supplementation.
- The mean fasting blood glucose level in experimental groups showed a reduction ranging from 17.5 to 21.7 mg/dl with E2 showing a higher decrease at 1% level of significance, whereas E4 showed a lower reduction. The final post prandial blood glucose levels of all the diabetics of the Experimental groups E1, E2, E3 and E4 found to decrease than the initial values except the control group after supplementation of spice capsules. The findings of glycosylated haemoglobin revealed that, one per cent significance was observed among group E2 while 5% significance was observed among experimental groups E1, E3 and E4 except control group which showed no difference significantly. The haemoglobin level of the diabetics revealed a significant increase at 1% level.
- The total cholesterol values of the diabetics revealed a higher difference among groups E2 and E4 at 1% level, whereas groups E1 and E3 at 5% level. The triglyceride levels of the diabetics after supplementation found that, there was a significant difference at 5% level among groups E1 and E3 and at 1% level among E2 and E4. LDL cholesterol level of the diabetics showed a significant reduction at 1% level among groups E2 and E4. There was a significant difference in HDL cholesterol values among groups E1, E3 and E4 at 5% level, whereas E2 and control group did not show any improvement. The mean VLDL cholesterol levels of the diabetics revealed a statistically significant reduction in mean VLDL levels. Supplementation of functional ingredient capsules showed a significant improvement in the bio chemical parameters. It is inferred from the results that supplementation of cloves and cinnamon brought down hypoglycemic and hypocholesterolemic effects on diabetics (40-60) years with normal diet.
Acknowledgements
The author shows gratitude towards the Nutrition Department of Avinashilingam University for Women, Coimbatore for the laboratory facilities and support to carry out the work successfully.
The author shows gratitude towards the Nutrition Department of Avinashilingam University for Women, Coimbatore for the laboratory facilities and support to carry out the work successfully.
References
- Allen NE., et al. “Hormones and diet, low-insulin like growth factor-but normal bioavailable androgens in vegan men”. British Journal of Cancer83.1(2000):93-97.
- Franz MJ., et al. “Nutrition Principles and Recommendations in diabetes.” Diabetes care 27 (2004): 36-46.
- American Diabetes Association. Diabetes Care 45 (2006): 56, P.29.
- Babu PS., et al. “Cinnamaldehyde- a potential antidiabetic agent”. Phytomedicine 14.1 (2006): 15-22.
- Babyskaria P., et al. “Horticulture science series-1, Aromatic Plants, New India Publishing Agency.” Pitampura, New Delhi, (2007): 73-91.
- Baker W., et al. “The effect of cinnamon on glucose control and lipid parameters”. Diabetes Care 31.1(2007): 41-43.
- Bharate R. Department of Natural Products, National Institute of Pharmaceutical Education and Research (NIPER), India, (2001): 34.
- Carl A Burtis., et al. Elsevier, Elsevier India Pvt Ltd., 17-A/1, Main Ring road, Laipat Nagar-IV, New Delhi, India, (2006): 915-955.
- Encyclopaedia of Medicinal Plants. Saunders Publishers (2000): 45-47.
- Falcon M. “Spices and condiments”. John Wiley Publications, New York. (2002). 3-13.
- Frank PM. “Monitoring the diabetic patient with HbA1c measurements’. Amer.Clinprod.Rev, (1988): 29-33.
- Friedewald WT., et al. "Estimation of the concentration of low-density lipoprotein cholesterol in plasma, without use of the preparative ultracentrifuge”. Clinical Chemistry 18.6 (1972): 499-502.
- HUDCO. “Housing Finance Publishing Division”, Patiala House, New Delhi (2004): 232.
- Jackicic JM., et al. “Effect of exercise duration and intensity on weight loss in over weight, sedentary women, A randomized trial.” JAMA 290.10 (2003): 1323-1330.
- Jakubowicz. “Effect of food consumption pattern among the diabetes”. ENDO Meeting (2008): 1686-1694.
- Khan A and Richard A. “Insulin potentiating factors in foods, spices and natural products.” Sahard Journal of Agriculture2.4(2003): 254-257.
- Neogi S. India, world diabetes capital, Hindustan times, Sept 3, (2007).
- NIN. A manual of laboratory techniques, National Institute of Nutrition, Indian Council of Medical Research, Hyderabad. (2005).
- Praful B and Godkar. Text book of Medical Laboratory, Bhalani publishing House, Mumbai, India (1998): 143-180.
- Rajamani S., et al. “Food seasoning spices mixture improves glucose metabolism and lipid profile in fructose-fed hyperinsulinemic rats.” Journal of Medicinal Foods 8.4 (2005): 502-507.
- Riccardi G., et al. “Role of glycemic index and glycemic load in the healthy state, in prediabetes and in diabetes.” American Journal of Clinical Nutrition87.1 (2008): 269-274.
- Sharma. Medicinal plants of India, Compendium of Industrial Research (2003): 98-112.
- Vasant lad. Natural health, (2004): 11-15.
- Verma IC. “Burden of genetic disorders in India”. Indian journal of pediatrics 67.12 (2000): 893-898.
- Walter J Daly and D Craig Brater. "Medieval contributions to the search for truth in clinical medicine". Perspectives in Biology and Medicine 43.4 (2000): 530-540.
- WHO. Technical Report, (1999): 886, P.2.
- WHO. Diabetes Care, world Health Forum, Who, Geneva, 16.4 (2004): 4-6.
Citation:
Dr. M Sivasakthi. “Efficacy of Supplementation of Cloves and Cinnamon Capsules on Type II Diabetics”. Nutrition and Food
Toxicology 1.4 (2017): 130-139.
Copyright: © 2017 Dr. M Sivasakthi. This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.